If eighteen months ago I was told
that losing Jean de Villiers for the 2014 June internationals would be a major
setback for the Springboks I would have politely advised the teller that in the
same vain it is a major setback that Mark Andrews has not made himself
available for selection. De Villiers looked well beyond international level but
praise must be given where it is due. Heyneke Meyer showed faith in de Villiers
and was richly rewarded. Not only he, but Alistair Coetzee has benefitted from
a rejuvenated player that is back to his signature-celebrating best (thank God
that seems to have passed).
The issue his absence presents is
not only who will don the number 12 jersey for the Springboks in the upcoming
run of fixtures but who will lead the side. The Boks do appear safe for cover
at centre as Sharks lock Stephan Lewies has been called up in de Villiers'
stead. Now Lewies hasn't featured at centre for the Sharks this season nor has
he even been allowed to hold a tackle bag for the backs in practice but we at ReRugby have
an inside source that can guarantee that Lewies was once seen sucking air out on
the wing during a game of touch in grade 5. Lewies has also been known to
frequent Gateway Centre in Umhlanga so all looks well.
Although the June internationals
are hardly pivotal in terms of results and silverware they prove a useful gauge for the Rugby Championship and, given the proximity of the IRB World Cup,
take on an extra importance this year. South African rugby supporters aren't the
most forgiving bunch at the best of times and Mr Meyer will know that anything
but a 100% win record on home soil will be a failure. So, who just are the
contenders to lead out the Bokke? Heyneke Meyer has dispelled the option of
rotating the captaincy and will look to give the job to the same player for all
four matches where the Springboks will feature against the World XV, Wales on
two occasions, and Scotland. Meyer has also assured us humble public that
whoever is chosen will be replaced by de Villiers upon his return so there is
not necessarily any long-term view on the choice.
The first option proves quite a
conundrum: Victor Matfield. Yes, it is true that Matfield who was dazzling the
South African public with his commentating acumen this very year is not only
back in the Springbok fold but is a frontrunner to lead the Bokke out onto the
field during these internationals. My God! Sure, the Boks are slightly Kate
Mossish (a bit thin) on the locking front, especially after Pieter-Steph du
Toit's injury, but Victor Matfield? In his defence (not about his defence), he
hasn’t actually been that bad for the Bulls this season. He leads the Super
Rugby stats for lineout wins which is an enviable and desirous stat to have for a lock to have but beanpole prowess shouldn't be the only item in a Springbok second-rower's bag of tricks. His general play in the loose and around the
fringes, as he has demonstrated over the years, shows an aversion to the aggressive stuff that would make Tinkerbelle
look like Achilles. There is no question that Matfield brings unrivaled experience and leadership to the team and does appear to have maintained at
least a steady level of fitness in his old age but is he a player of Springbok
quality? Arguably what he brings in terms of experience and know-how is what
the team may need given the high number of young players in the squad. Can he
add this from the bench or just in training? Yes, but Meyer will want on-field
leadership from a player who will start each match. Matfield may just be the
option.
Bismarck du Plessis is a strong
choice. Bissy has captained the Sharks well this season and has maintained his
physical, domineering self with the added responsibility. He has been known to
lapse into a state of blind rage but that is probably still directed at his
agent for allowing him to appear in the 'pump by die dam pump' advert. In my
mind, Bismarck is South Africa's best player. Adriaan Strauss is good, yes, but
Bissy is simply too strong a force. Strauss has also been put forward as a
possibility to lead the Boks but in truth the likelihood of Meyer rotating the
two may actually rule them both out of the running. Bismarck is an option to
take over the captaincy from de Villiers after next year's World Cup but it
appears Meyer's mind is fixed on the short term for now.
Heyneke Meyer has also put
forward the names of Schalk Burger and Duane Vermuelen as options. No
disrespect meant but Schalk hasn't played enough to warrant a spot in the
starting fifteen and arguably in the squad at all. I don’t have a major issue
with him cracking the nod for the wider squad but there are far superior loose
forwards in the country at the moment who should rule him out of the run-on fifteen. Duane Vermuelen is surely a no-go. Although he hasn't really had the
best Super Rugby season, he will be the favourite to start at eight for the
Boks, but captain? I can’t see it happening.
In my mind, Bismarck is the long term
replacement for de Villiers. He won’t present the same kind of selection issues
that plagued John Smit and is growing as a leader with the Sharks but for now
that won’t help him. The way things appear, Meyer will pick Matfield. It's not a
terrible call. He is almost sure to start and given Meyer's primary aim to get his
team out of the inbound tour unscathed, old Vic gives him a strong figure around whom to
build his team. Quite frankly I don't care, just so long as it keeps Matfield away from a microphone.